Most Romantic Valentine’s Day Jewelry Gifts

oval solitaire engagement ring stacked with graduated baguette diamond band on hand

When it comes to romance, Valentine’s Day is the perfect time to pull out all the plugs and find the most meaningful (and tangible!) ways to show your love. Jewelry is a classic choice for a reason: it has beautiful symbolism, can last a lifetime or more, and can be worn often as a constant reminder of your love and connection. We’re here to help you find the perfect piece to show your love this Valentine's Day! From brilliant diamond studs and tennis bracelets to symbolic Toi et Moi designs, you'll find all the thoughtful details to make the best gift right here with our most romantic jewelry gift ideas.

Pour on the Sparkle with Diamond Martini Stud Earrings

three-prong gold and diamond stud earrings

Why stop at a sparkling drink when your love could enjoy these Martini Mounting Diamond Studs every day? Featuring a carat of lab-grown diamonds and a sophisticated three-prong setting, these stud earrings are a brilliant choice for a romantic jewelry gift!

Give a Flower that Lasts with the Poppy Necklace

poppy necklace with lab-grown diamond

This adorable bloom is the flower that lasts forever! The Poppy Necklace is delicate and intricate, with a tiny mine-free diamond nestled in the center of the blossom for extra sparkle. To make this romantic jewelry gift a matching set, add our Poppy Earrings.

Celebrate You and Me with the Petite Toi et Moi Ring

petite toi et moi diamond ring and petite croissant ring on a hand

Toi et Moi rings are the trend with symbolic appeal. Featuring two diamonds representing “You and Me,” this style takes the cake in the romantic jewelry gift category. In the Petite Toi et Moi Ring, a pear-shaped diamond nestles up to an emerald-cut diamond, celebrating the closeness and distinctiveness of a committed couple. It’s hard to get more romantic than that with this Valentine’s Day jewelry for her!

Score a Win with the Classic Lab-Grown Diamond Tennis Bracelet

three sizes of diamond tennis bracelets modeled on a wrist

Whether you play tennis or not, there’s no denying the allure of the Classic Lab-Grown Diamond Tennis Bracelet. The line of diamonds sparkles from every angle and with every turn of the wrist. Choose your favorite size, from 2ct to 7ct, and customize with your choice of gold color. This romantic jewelry gift is a real head-turner and sure to please!

Put a Pink Twist On the Toi et Moi Trend with the Toi et Moi Padparadscha and Peachy-Pink Sapphire Necklace

Rose gold and pink sapphire two-stone necklace

This gorgeous piece combines the romance of a symbolic Toi et Moi design with the gorgeous blush tones of warm-toned sapphires and glowy rose gold. The colors in this necklace live somewhere between a dreamy beach sunset and a raspberry sorbet! The Toi et Moi Padparadscha and Peachy-Pink Sapphire Necklace hangs at just the right length on an 18-inch chain. For something extra-special with a twist of unexpected, this Valentine’s Day jewelry gift hits the mark!

Give the Ultimate Romantic Jewelry Gift – An Engagement Ring! Featuring the Stevie Ring with a Radiant Diamond

Hand wearing radiant bezel Stevie ring

The ultimate romantic Valentine’s Day jewelry gift is, of course, an engagement ring! Check out our Radiant Stevie bezel solitaire engagement ring, recently featured on The Knot. Thoughtfully designed for aesthetic perfection and maximum sparkle, Stevie’s details are what make her such a popular choice! Make your Valentine’s Day proposal a sparkling success with our take on the perfect bezel engagement ring.

More Romantic Jewelry Gift Ideas

If you’re looking for a different Valentine’s Day jewelry for her, check out our wedding bands, more earrings, and other ready-to-ship gift ideas in our gift guide. If you don’t find what you’re looking for, feel free to reach out to our team. We can help you find the perfect Valentine’s Day jewelry gift, or design a custom piece to express your love in a personal way. No matter how you decide to celebrate this Valentine’s Day, there’s nothing sweeter than letting your person know how you feel about them, and a little sparkle goes a long way!